Disagreement Conference – Montreal, May 26-28, 2016

Faces of Disagreement – Montreal, May 26-28, 2016
Les visages du désaccord – Montréal, 26-28 mai 2016

(1) Event summary
(2) Programme

Table ronde: « Les goûts, ça se discute ! »
Public roundtable on gustatory disagreements

(3) People
(4) Practical info
(5) Support

(1) Event summary

As is well known, we disagree about all sorts of things, from factual matters to normative matters, that is, about what we shall or should do. But if disagreements are all too familiar, their nature and significance are far from well understood. This conference aims to investigate the various aspects of disagreement, by proposing an as yet unexplored comparative analysis of this transversal phenomenon.

Among the questions that will be addressed are: What do we really disagree about when we disagree about normative issues? Are normative disagreements about how things are in the world, or are they disagreements in desires or preferences? Answering questions like these will illuminate the nature of our disagreements. Another set of questions will target the significance of disagreement. Should we give our opponents’ opinions the same weight as our own, in virtue of the fact that, even if they disagree with us, we take them to be as reasonable as we are? Does this mean that we should adopt an attitude of neutrality toward the contested topic? And if so, what are the consequences for public policies and other matters of collective concern?

The main programme will be completed by a roundtable on disagreements about gustatory taste, aimed at an educated but non-specialist public, featuring Christine Tappolet, Marc-Antoine Dilhac and Jean Aubry. The language of the main programme of the conference will be English, while the public roundtable will be held in French.

Invited speakers:

  • Annalisa Coliva (University of Modena/University of California at Irvine)
  • Daniel Groll (Carleton College)
  • Carrie Ichikawa Jenkins (University of British Columbia)
  • Chris McMahon (University of California at Santa Barbara)
  • Tristram McPherson (Ohio State University)
  • Jonathan Quong (University of Southern California)
  • Gurpreet Rattan (University of Toronto)
  • Russ Shafer-Landau (University of North Carolina)
  • Isidora Stojanovic (CNRS, Institut Jean Nicod)
  • Ralph Wedgwood (University of Southern California, University of Birmingham)

Selected speakers:

  • Jaakko Hirvelä (University of Helsinki)
  • Nikolas Kirby (Oxford University)
  • Rachel Rudolph (University of California at Berkeley)

Table ronde: « Les goûts, ça se discute ! »

Cette table-ronde rassemblera Jean Aubry (chroniqueur, Le Devoir), Marc-Antoine Dilhac (Université de Montréal), Christine Tappolet (Université de Montréal) ainsi qu’un animateur des débats.

Public roundtable on gustatory disagreements

The main programme will be complemented by a roundtable on gustatory disagreements, aimed at an educated but non-specialised public, featuring Jean Aubry (Le Devoir), Marc-Antoine DIlhac (Université de Montréal) and Christine Tappolet (Université de Montréal). The language of the main programme of the conference will be English, while the public roundtable will be held in French.

⇧ Back to top

(2) Programme

Please note that this conference is preceded, on May 25th, by a roundtable on Ralph Wedgwood’s forthcoming book The Normativity of Rationality

26.05.16, Université de Montréal: Salon François-Chevrette, salle A3464, Pavillon Maximilien-CaronMap

9:00-9:10 Mot d’ouverture, Tania Saba, Doyenne de la Faculté des Arts et des Sciences, UdeM

9:10-10:30 Jonathan Quong (USC), “Disagreement, Equality, and the Exclusion of Ideals” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary : Danielle Zwarthoed (CRÉ)

10:40-12:00 Chris McMahon (UC Santa Barbara), “The Reasonableness of Reasonable Disagreement” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: François Boucher (CRÉ)


1:30-2:50 Nikolas Kirby (Oxford), “We are All Free and Equal”
Commentary: Arash Abizadeh (McGill)

3:00-4:20 Daniel Groll (Carleton College), “The Disagreements that Drive Paternalism” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: Angela Martin (CRÉ)

4:30-5:50 Carrie Ichikawa Jenkins (UBC), “All Hearts in Love Use Their Own Tongues: Concepts, Verbal Disputes, and Disagreeing about Love” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: Hichem Naar (CRÉ)

7:00-8:30 Table-ronde publique « Les goûts, ça se discute ! », Librairie Olivieri


27.05.16, McGill University: room 12, McConnell Engineering (just inside the Milton Gates at the corner of University and Milton – Map)

9:10-10:30 Annalisa Coliva (UC Irvine), “Disagreeing with Myself”
Commentary: Dominic Alford-Duguid (Toronto)

10:40-12:00 Michele Palmira (Barcelona), “Disagreement, Significance, and Revision” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: Marc-Kevin Daoust (Montréal)


1:30-2:50 Isidora Stojanovic (CNRS), “Expressing Disagreement” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: Ethan Jerzak (UC Berkeley)

3:00-4:20 Rachel Rudolph (UC Berkeley), “Differences of Taste” (Abstract – PDF)
Commentary: David Hunter (Ryerson)

4:30-5:50 Gurpreet Rattan (Toronto) & Genoveva Martí (ICREA/University of Barcelona), “Intersubjective Opacity and Hierarchy”
Commentary: Oran Magal (McGill)

8:00-10:00 souper/dinner


28.05.16, Université de Montréal: Salon François-Chevrette, salle A3464, Pavillon Maximilien-CaronMap

9:10-10:30 Ralph Wedgwood (USC), “Moral Disagreement and Inexcusable Irrationality” (Paper – PDF)
Commentary: Jakob Reckhenrich (Brown)

10:40-12:00 Jaakko Hirvelä (Helsinki), “Is it Safe to Disagree?”
Commentary: Miriam McCormick (Richmond)


1:30-2:50 Tristram McPherson (Ohio State), “The Epistemology of Joint-Carving Normative Realism”
Commentary: Felix Beaudoin (Laval)

3:00-4:20 Russ Shafer-Landau (UNC), “Moral Disagreement and Moral Intuitions”
Commentary: Samuel Dishaw (Montreal)

⇧ Back to top

(3) People

Organising committee:

  • Andrée-Anne Cormier (McGill University, CRÉ)
  • Michele Palmira (University of Barcelona, LOGOS)
  • Sarah Stroud (McGill University)
  • Christine Tappolet (Université de Montréal)

Reviewers of submitted manuscripts:

  • Arash Abizadeh (McGill University)
  • Aude Bandini (Cégep Édouard-Montpetit)
  • Yves Bouchard (Université de Sherbrooke)
  • François Boucher (Université de Montréal, CRÉ)
  • Murray Clarke (Concordia University)
  • François Claveau (Université de Sherbrooke)
  • Andrée-Anne Cormier (McGill University, CRÉ)
  • Marc-Antoine Dilhac (Université de Montréal)
  • Daniel Laurier (Université de Montréal)
  • Gregory Lavers (Concordia University)
  • Hichem Naar (Université de Montréal, CRÉ)
  • Michele Palmira (University of Barcelona, LOGOS)
  • Andrew Reisner (Uppsala University)
  • Sarah Stroud (McGill University)
  • Christine Tappolet (Université de Montréal)
  • Patrick Turmel (Université Laval)
  • Alain Voizard (Université du Québec à Montréal)
  • Danielle Zwarthoed (Université de Montréal, CRÉ)

Support to the organising committee:

  • Marc-Kevin Daoust (Université de Montréal)

⇧ Back to top

(4) Practical info

From the airport to Montreal

Suggested hotels

Suggested restaurants

⇧ Back to top

(5) Support

Centre de Recherche en Éthique (CRÉ)
Conseil de recherches en sciences humaines
Faculty of Arts, McGill University
Canadian Journal of Philosophy
Faculté des Arts et Sciences, Université de Montréal
Groupe de Recherche Interuniversitaire sur la Normativité (GRIN)
Department of Philosophy, McGill University
Département de philosophie, Université de Montréal

⇧ Back to top